Search
← Problems

Two expressions that cannot both be cubes

For an integer \(n\geq0\), prove that

\[n+2\qquad\text{and}\qquad n^2+n+1\]

cannot both be perfect cubes.

Hint

Assume \(n+2\) is a cube, then compare the second expression with consecutive cubes.

Solution

Suppose \(n+2=a^3\) and \(n^2+n+1=b^3\) for positive integers \(a,b\). Then \(a\geq2\) and

\[b^3=a^6-3a^3+3<a^6.\]

For the preceding cube,

\[\begin{gathered} b^3-(a^2-1)^3\\ =3a^2(a^2-a-1)+4>0, \end{gathered}\]

since \(a^2-a-1\geq1\). Thus

\[(a^2-1)^3<b^3<(a^2)^3.\]

This traps a perfect cube strictly between consecutive cubes, which is impossible.

Find a post, puzzle, or idea.